The Arctic is Screaming: A Trillion Dollar Problem

by

NBS Thought Leaders offer guidance on sustainable business models for the 21st century. Thought Leaders are leading academics and practitioners: world experts on sustainability issues. Here, Gail Whiteman describes the importance of picking up on early signs of big changes. Dr. Whiteman describes how the warming Arctic is an “economic time-bomb” – and how business should react. Dr. Whiteman is Professor-in-Residence at the World Business Council for Sustainable Development and Chair in Sustainability & Climate Change at Erasmus University, The Netherlands.

What we don’t notice can hurt us. We are good at monitoring our immediate environment: competitive activity, consumer demographics, employee culture. When our world is stable, we don’t need to expand our focus.

But shifts in stability often begin with weak, almost invisible, cues — indications that are easily overlooked.

Take the economic downturn. Questionable lending in housing markets and rapidly evolving financial instruments could have caused concern.

But regulators — and the financial system more broadly — missed the cues.

Our observations — our “sensemaking processes” — tend to reinforce our existing worldviews. That’s why experts like Karl Weick advise us to pay close attention to surprises, and to stories from experts on the front-line.

Front-line: Arctic

In 2007, the Earth experienced an abrupt surprise: a record Arctic ice melt. The Arctic ice retreats every summer, but never this much: the volume of Arctic sea ice at summer's end was half what it was four years earlier. “The Arctic is screaming,” a top U.S government scientist said.

Last fall, the Arctic sent another message loud and clear. Arctic ice reached a new all-time low: almost 300,000 square miles less than in 2007. But were we listening?

What the melting Arctic means for business

Less Arctic ice represents economic opportunity to some executives and governments. The Arctic contains an estimated 30% of the world’s undiscovered gas and 13% of undiscovered oil. This means tempting short-term economic benefits to Arctic regions, especially with the increased feasibility of new shipping routes. Lloyds of London estimates that “investment in the Arctic could reach $100 billion within ten years.”

But the changing Arctic will have greater and more damaging impacts, because of the region’s central role in stabilizing the Earth’s climate. Ice in the Arctic reflects sunlight, helping to cool the Earth. Less white in the Great White North means that the Earth will absorb more heat, increasing global warming.

In addition, large stores of methane — a potent greenhouse gas — are trapped in soil (permafrost) under the ice. When the ice melts, that methane may escape, further increasing warming.

In new research published in the journal Nature, my colleagues and I found that this methane release, because of its effects on climate, will have a cost the size of the world economy: $60 trillion. We used UK and US government models to identify the impacts: the damage to crops, health, infrastructure and other resources.

Taking action

Our world is shifting, and the cues are there. How can we make sense of what’s happening, and respond appropriately?

We need to listen more closely to the scientists who study the Arctic carefully. And we need to consider how best to act on this knowledge: how to mitigate and adapt to such big shocks?

Increasingly, governments, industry associations, and others are providing guidance on how climate change will affect sectors, and how to prepare. For example, North American regional impacts are described by the US government’s Global Change program and Natural Resources Canada. A recent NBS Thought Leader piece identifies ways that business can become involved in climate policy.

Surprises can teach us. We must recognize that what happens at our planet’s pole can affect our daily lives.

Additional Resources

More information on our recent research on “the vast costs of Arctic change”

An overview of risks and opportunities in the Arctic, from Lloyd’s of London: Arctic opening: Opportunity and risk in the high north

 

About the Author

Dr. Gail Whiteman is Professor and Chair, Sustainability and Climate Change, at Rotterdam School of Management, Erasmus University (The Netherlands). Professor-Whiteman combines her role at RSM with that of part time Professor in-Residence at the World Business Council for Sustainable Development (WBCSD). She is co-founder and Director of the Centre for Corporate Eco-Transformation, where she collaborates with multinational companies to examine issues such as the strategic role of companies in their transition towards low carbon, sustainable cities; the impact of natural resource extraction on local sustainability; and the drivers of sustainable innovation. She is also active in innovative business sustainability training and education.