Greening Blue Jeans: Insights from a New Competitor Collaboration

A team of rivals is making the denim industry more sustainable. NBS research guides the collaboration.
Garima Sharma September 23, 2017
The global denim industry is criticized for water waste, polluting processes, and labor violations. For example, in Xingtang, China, the “blue jeans capital of the world,” the local river runs denim black from dyes and other chemicals.

A possible solution to the industry’s challenges: competitor collaboration. When an issue — like pollution or worker safety — matters to an entire industry, it can make sense for competitors to come together to find answers.

Competitor collaborations bring cutthroat rivals together to share ideas and find solutions. And the results can be amazing: new technologies, shared standards, effective government policies.

But these collaborations aren’t easy, as rivals try to become a team.

Denim industry leaders in Amsterdam have taken this high-risk, high-rewards approach, founding the Alliance for Responsible Denim (ARD). They’re building on pioneering NBS research on competitor collaboration, developed by Dr. Lori DiVito (Amsterdam University of Applied Sciences).

DiVito is directly involved in ARD. She is sharing her knowledge and working with managers to shape ARD’s structure and agenda.

Dutch Leadership on Denim

Amsterdam is an internationally renowned centre of denim expertise. It’s a place where international denim brands have design centres, international denim suppliers and mills have local offices, and young brands begin. It’s also the hub for sustainability innovation in the denim industry.

ARD brings together denim brands and suppliers with industry experts and stakeholders. Together, they focus on (1) increasing the use of post-consumer recycled denim and (2) establishing measurements, benchmarks and standards for use of resources such as chemicals, water, and energy.

A Team of Rivals

It can be hard for companies used to fighting tooth and nail to work together effectively. Research shows that 90 per cent of executives recognize the importance of sustainability collaboration in general, but only 47 per cent actively collaborate. Involvement in competitor collaboration is significantly rarer.

Here's what companies in ARD have learned about working together.

Challenges are real.

Having different types of members in the collaboration increases impact, but causes tensions. James Veenhoff of the House of Denim, a denim industry think tank and ARD member, praises that diversity. "It's unique that we have big and small denim brands together with suppliers working on these sustainability issues,” he says. “It’s the only way to progress and change the industry.” But companies come at the topic from different positions, and not everybody wants the same thing. Companies have:
People are busy. ARD requires each brand to attend a quarterly three-hour working group meeting. Brands also work with ARD coordinators between meetings to gather data such as production information from their suppliers and product specifications from the brand’s internal teams.

This level of engagement is not for the faint of heart. If the brands do not see value, and see it quickly, they are quick to disengage.  “There are a lot of sustainability initiatives in the apparel industry,” DiVito explains, “so brands see a duplication and have to decide where to engage."

Competition is everywhere. Competition hides on multiple levels in the value chain. Competing brands, competing suppliers, competing initiatives. All these can affect dynamics within the collaboration.

Keep team spirit alive.

To address these challenges and provide value, ARD has taken these strategies:
  1. Communicate. Constant, frank communication is key. DiVito has a team member dedicated to communication with participating companies. Company staff can share concerns with him in one-on-one conversations. He also lightens their workload for ARD by collecting needed data in conversation with the companies or their suppliers.
  2. Accept that no one can be forced to have fun at the party. Not every participating company will have the same level of engagement. Speaking about the brands that do not want to be publicly associated with sustainability, DiVito explains: “These brands acknowledge that there is no other solution but the sustainable one, so they are at the table. But they are not ready to openly communicate their commitment, and that’s okay.” She expects that involvement will gradually increase their interest.
  3. Provide value along the way — and celebrate. Companies have committed to ARD for a minimum of two years. That short timeline makes it easier for companies to commit resources — but isn't actually enough time to achieve the necessary transformation. To keep companies involved, DiVito works to have valuable takeaways from every meeting. These are intriguing discoveries like the impact of different denim finishing; and real products, like the development of a shared recycled denim fabric, or changes to production processes. “Meetings should show progress and provide learning,” says DiVito. ARD also celebrates each milestone. For example, all brands signed a pair of denim jeans at ARD’s kickoff (see below). Simple gestures go a long way in sustaining commitment.
  4. Have a referee. The collaboration manager should be a trusted neutral party without commercial interests. That person can identify tensions between different interests and support dialogue to find common ground. Finding that that neutral person can be tricky. Relevant nonprofits may have commercial interests, either in direct revenue from the collaboration or in indirect revenue from follow-on consultancy.

Rivals are relevant.

A competitor collaboration is a bit like a meeting of sports heroes. There are tensions, but also a sense of being with peers that can be powerful and positive. Competitors rarely sit at the same table exchanging information and ideas. Yet as professionals in the same industry, they are aware of each other. Competitors want to benchmark themselves and compare their progress or behaviour.

Building on that interest and engagement can change the world.

Find out more

Alliance for Responsible Denim

Related resources

Executive Report

Collaborations can be tense and complex. This tool responds to the question: How can managers improve competitor collaboration to advance sustainability.

NBS
Systematic Review

This guide enables managers to make the case for a competitor collaboration to colleagues or leaders, and determine satisfaction with current projects. 

NBS
Topic Blog

In this video, Dr. DiVito illustrates what managers who are considering competitor collaboration need to know.

NBS
Article

Pooling resources, intelligence, leadership, and common sustainability goals with other companies, even with competitors, can elevate the level of results.

NBS
News and Events

NBS invites you to our upcoming breakfast forum and workshop, Collaborating with the Competition, taking place on September 9, 2016 in Toronto.

NBS

Alliance for Responsible Denim meeting, January 2017